Sigma 180 Macro Lens Review

Sigma 180 Macro Lens Review

Sigma 180 Macro Lens Review

10012 4

One year testing

TrueToad
/ Categories: My Reviews

Compatibility: If you are considering a move to the Nikon Mirrorless Z camera be advised the Sigma 180mm Macro lens may NOT be compatible + this lens is not compatible with Sigma's Lens Dock thus updating the lens firmware is only available via a Sigma Service Center. * Please see Sigma Compatibility list before buying Sigma lens. * Compatibility may apply to lenses sold prior to the Nikon Z Camera Release, Sigma has addressed some incompatibility for their newer lenses. If you are buying used - be advised.

If you are a DSLR shooter this is a fantastic macro lens on par with the legendary Nikkor 200mm for sharpness.

I have taken hundreds of images with this lens, and every-time it delivers excellent results. What I like most about this Sigma 180 full frame Macro lens is how pleasing the colors and sharpness are right inside the camera.  The lens design and glass adds wonderful contrast to the images, and the overall color reproduction accuracy simplifies post-processing.  I don't really need to do much to the images once I get them into lightroom, but also to note is the fact I don't generally do much processing to images anyway.  My post-processing is to remove noise, I may adjust/balance of light and dark areas, followed by some contrast adjustments and finally adjust the white balance, not necessary as I take a color checker with me on my trips.    Sharpening? With today's lens, I rarely do any other than in camera.

How I used this lens: I have two long Macro lens 1. a Nikkor 200mm and 2. this Sigma 180mm.  The lens can fill in as a lens that is suitable for a number of photography choirs. Well - Macro, and generally a nice medium telephoto, and also a Portraiture lens,  and quite frankly does a good job at all three.  I bought mine for macro, and so that is a way if have primarily used it for. 

Image
As a Macro lens it rocks - It is a true macro lens. You can rest assured this lens will deliver high-quality performance and sharpness. I believe it to be the best macro from Sigma and challenges both Canon and Nikon glass optically.  The images are not as flat and sharp edge to edge as say my Nikkor 200mm, but I do not use the lens for flat objects, I take images of nature so to me it does not matter.

What I liked:  Very fine detail and sharpness at the macro range and as good when used as a standard medium telephoto, delivers good contrast and nice colors with the ability to show some bokeh at f/2.8. The lens performs well in the field but be advised this is a "heavy" lens.  And when I say heavy the sigma is a FULL Pound heavier than the Nikkor 200mm, sigma is 3.6 pounds, while the Nikkor is 2.6 pounds.  The weight does matter, especially in macro when most of your subjects are close to the ground, bending over with the lens and DSLR is a choir; 

What is so so: The front lens hood is cheap-plastic and hard to attach securely, Sigma needs to address better hood attachments for all their lens. The case is also crap and cheaply made but does the job.  In Sigma's defense, some improvement was made to address the lens hood on their newer lens, but their cases are awful.

Image
Optical Performance: I find this lens to have excellent optical performance with a high degree of quality throughout. I can acquire sharp images both hand-holding using the OS or when on a tripod, the results can be amazing, while hand holding the lens is very good but not as good as my Nikkor 105 handheld with VR. Consider this lens is almost twice the focal length, so this lens is near as good but I can not determine a true winner.  

Focus: Although the Sigma is speedy my Nikkor 105 has faster focus, but the Sigma beats the Nikkor 200mm in focus speed but not in sharpness.  However, unlike the Nikkor 105, the Sigma lens has very minimal focal breathing, this is important for focus stacking. My 105 Nikkor changes size as you focus making it difficult to stack focus. I try to avoid stacking by posting my sensor plane to the subject, but this technique is not always possible, stuff in the way!. So, Sigma focus is fast enough for me as a Macro lens and good enough for medium telephoto general photography. If you use continuous focus mode in your camera, the sigma will clatter a bit as it maintains focus on your subject and for macro small movements will produce a lot of clatter.  I do not find it too objectionable, but it is distracting.

Stabilization: Sigma calls it OS Nikon calls it VR.  I say both works when used properly, I found no fault in Sigmas OS used on this lens, I get nicely detailed images on the rare occasions I hand hold, when engaged you will hear a click then slight release when the image is taken, nothing too loud.  Your biggest challenge out in the field is the wind, and stabilization does not address that - a combination of fast focus tracking and OS will.

Image
Concerns: This lens is heavy. Be advised on this, if you are a freewheeler hand-holder who likes going around hand-holding - this lens will tax you.  Please: consider carrying a small tripod with a quick release to allow trouble-free carry or a beautiful Black Rapid strap that helps to remove the strain, but a tripod, in my opinion, is better, when set up with a quick release.

Hand holding> I get about 75% good sharp images.  Maybe I am slow and old, on a tripod, I get 90% sharp images - wind plays into this, and no wind = 99% sharp images on the tripod.

Overall Thoughts:  Yes, this is a very nice Macro Lens and is what I use it for, Overall I do not find any major fault in the optics or image stabilization both seem to work well. If you are looking for a longer macro,  this lens should be close to the top of your list.

Good luck in your Macro work, if you need advice give me a shout in the comments below.

Print
Rate this article:
4.6
Photographer's Notes

Buy your Sigma 180mm Macro Lens

Comment

Iverson · 4/14/2019 8:33:55 PM

Sigma 180mm 2.8 macro or Nikkor 200mm f4 macro for long a long macro? Thanks.

TrueToad · 4/18/2019 11:31:56 AM

I really love the Nikkor 200mm f/4 optic wise is excellent but focus controls and speeds are dated by today's standards.

The Sigma is faster, has Optical Stabilization and Focus limiting + due to the faster aperture and OS the Sigma 180mm lens is more versatile and cheaper.

If I were buying a long macro today I would get the SIGMA.

Hopefully one day Nikon will update the 200mm f4 lens.

Iverson White · 4/28/2019 7:19:56 PM

Thanks. I am leaning toward the Sigma, but a Nikkor 200mm just came into my local camera store on consignment. They haven't priced it yet but the manager said it will be priced well below eBay, so I'm thinking $700-$800. That might be too good to pass up.

I played around with it today and discovered that it's only f4 when focused at infinity. Does the Sigma behave the same way?

Thanks again.

IW

TrueToad · 4/30/2019 8:00:12 AM

The Nikkor 200mm is an f/4 and as such will behave as you mentioned - the Sigma is an f/2.8 lens. If set to f/2.8 it will maintain that aperture regardless of focus.

Bottom line a nice 200mm at a good price is an excellent choice, keep in mind if moving to a Z camera body you will lose autofocus. Which applies to all D lenses.

You are replaying to

Your comment was added, but it must be approved first.

Please enter your name
Please enter your email adress Please enter valid email adress
Please enter a comment
Please solve Captcha.
Add Comment

Buy Your New Camera Using My Amazon Link

Photography Reviews, and Information

Nikon Z Teleconverter TC-1.4x Review

As a primary wildlife and Bird photographer, I am constantly looking for ways to close distance to the wildlife I am after to photograph. The Nikon teleconverter can make a big difference between success and failure.

Nissin MF18 Ring Flash Review

My main go-to for Macro Photography has been the Nikon awesome RIC1 Macro Flash system.  I decided to step outside the Nikon umbrella and get myself a Ring Flash to go along with my New S 105mm Macro Lens.

Nikon 70-200mm f/2.8E FL ED VR Lens Review

This is not a comparison between various 70-200mm lenses 3rd party lens manufacture.  This review is based on my experience using the Nikkor 70-200 ED FL zoom lens from Nikon. My expectations when I made the purchase was very high given the price point.  So, how has this lens performed?

Nikon Z 6II Review

The New Nikon Z 6II is here and what does it bring to the table?  A lot in the shortest sentence I can type. The Nikon Z 6II is one awesome camera - and did I say it does top-notch video?

Nikon 500mm F/5.6 PF Lens Review

In August 2018 Nikon announced the release of a compact super telephoto - the 500mm f/5.6E PF ED VR  Making this their second Phase Fresnel lens the first being the awesome 300mm PF PF/4. I am excited to see Nikon introduce this new prime lens at a sub 4k.  Let's run through the technical details as it relates to weight, compactness, and sharpness.  All of which are expected to be superior.

Nikon D850 Review

The Nikon D850 camera when release soon became lauded as a game-changing DSLR and now that I have mine let me give you my opinion not that Nikon Mirrorless Z cameras have become widely available.

Nikon Z7 vs Nikon Z7 II Which one to buy?

Nikon Z7 vs Nikon Z7 II: Nikon has made several key improvements to the Nikon Z7 II mirrorless camera by adding a second-generation body that supports dual card slots and a second EXPEED processor.  Now the question is which camera should you buy or should you upgrade you Z7 or DSLR?  Without the techno ramblings, this article is a simplified recommendation.

Nikon 400mm f/2.8E ED FL Review

Nikon AF-S Nikkor 400MM f/2.8E ED FL VR Lens:

2020 update ... The Nikkor 400mm 2.8 ed fl is an exceptional lens known for its flexibility and amazingly sharp images. Lighter and more nimble than it's predecessors but all the while retaining and improving on an already great Nikkor 400 heritage, this lens will bring to the photographic market a continued, appreciated, and highly sought after photographic instrument.  The Nikon AF-S Nikkor 400MM f/2.8E ED FL VR Lens is an excellent lens.

NIKON 400mm f2.8 lens review

Help This Site: Buy a Nikkor 400mm

Nikon 600mm f/4 FL ED Lens Review

Nikon 600mm f4 lens review: Almost 2 years since the last big 600mm lens release,  Nikon announced a stunning update to an already spectacular Super Telephoto lens; the new Nikkor 600mm f/4 FL ED VR lens, and just how could any manufacture make this wonderful lens faster, lighter, and better?  Let's find out.

Nikon Z 14-24mm f/2.8 S Lens - Review

After waiting almost two years for Nikon to release the new Nikon 14-24 f/2.8 S lens it has finally arrived!  One of my favorite lenses to shoot with and use. This New Lens, Allows for sun and other light sources in your composition due to the superior Anti-reflective Nano Crystal Coat (N) and ARNEO (A) coatings which virtually eliminate flare, ghosting, and coma by suppressing incidental light coming from any direction.

Nikon Battery Grip MB-N10 - Review

The Nikon MB-N10 is a Multi Battery Power Pack designed for the Nikon Z7 and Z6 mirrorless cameras. This grip/power pack extends the run time and offers a counter-balance when using long super-telephoto lenses.

Nikon D500 Camera Review

Since it's release the D500 is reported to be one of Nikon's best DX offerings to date, and I agree - It is a solid high-performance camera.  I share my thoughts and experience after months of solid use. The Nikon D500 has many technical benefits of the D5 making it a super sports camera, fast and agile with reasonable files that are easy to off load, process, and store. and after un-boxing in April my journey has begun, Read on ......


rss_feedRSS