Baader Calcium K-Line Filter vs Continuum
Review and Comparisions
Baader Calcium K-Line Filter in 1.25 filter size: The Baader Calcium K-Line Filter arrives in a 9 x 12 sealed plastic envelope with a set of instructions, a sheet of Baader AstroSolar Film (ND 3.8) and the filter which is inside a small plastic filter holder inside a box. For an average cost of around $ 350.00 depending on where you make your purchase.
PLEASE NOTE: Re-sellers normally make the statement that All Sales Final, due to the inclusion of the solar film. So, if your not happy with the results - your stuck.
Baader Solar Continuum Filter in 2" filter size: The Baader Continuum filter is a 2" filter and arrives in a hard plastic case, inside the badder box. The filter is designed to screw onto an eyepiece, camera, or other threaded accessories.
The Solar Set Up: Both the K-line and Continuum filters were used with the same telescope, a ZWO-ASI174mm Camera, a Baader ND 3.0 filter, and a Baader Herschel Wedge mounted on a 80mm refactor. This helps keep the playing field even, with images taken with the same optics.
Regardless of which filter you use you must have the necessary "white light" filter in place, either at the front or use a Solar wedge. With the Calcium K-Line it comes with a 8 x 11 sheet of Baader's ND-3 solar film, regarded as very good quality.
Following my long wait, anticipation and high expectations I was excited to see just how well this new Calcium Filter performed. My first challenge was overcoming the backfocus issue when using the camera with a nose piece; that did not work. So, I had to direct mount the camera onto the Baader Herschel wedge and this presented a second problem. I did not have the proper filter adapter to allow the 1.25 filter to be screwed into the 2" filter holder in my current setup. But, I had a neat work around - using some dense foam I was able to secure the filter in place perfectly. After some camera adjustments, I was off and imaging.
Because both the K-Line and Continuum filters do not have tuning adjustments your images are based on the activity of the sun that day; unlike HA Pressure tuned setups, you can not "tune" anything to increase detail with these screw in filters. Best you can hope for is use the exposure and contrast setting on your capture camera, or obviously in post processing to bring out the details.
The Baader Continuum being a 2" design allowed me to screw it direct onto the Baader filter holder into the wedge - a tedious task made simple by Baader's design. I now have a filter insert for the 1.25 calcium K shipping from Agena AstroProducts.
A note about Agena AstroProducts - This is by far one of the best on-line businesses, Super Fast, reasonable prices with excellent customer support. If you need filters, adapters, even Telescopes don't hesitate to visit and do business. Excellent! here is the link to Agena AstroProducts.
Calcium K & Continuum Filters side by side
This image helps illustrate the subtle differences between the Calcium K-line and Continuum filters
In the side by side comparison you can see what I believe is the slight increase of details shown in the Baader Calcium K-Line images vs the Continuum filter. I made several images over the course of days and was very pleased with the details the Calcium K-Line produced, overall the K-Line produces more contrast and renders more detail than the Continuum filter.
Also included in this gallery are other images taken with the Lunt LS80HA double stacked solar telescope along with an image taken with the continuum filter earlier in the year when the sun spots were more active, unfortunately I did not yet have the Baader Calcium K-Line filter at that time for comparisons.
Given the price point of the Baader Calcium K-Line and the fact it can only be used for imaging, I feel the Continuum filter is a cheaper solution for overall enjoyment of the sun's solar spots and sharing with others visually; of course with the correct configuration.
If you have a need to do imaging rather than viewing then the Calcium K-Line is a great option. To me it seems pricey for what you get, I think most people who are sun watchers will eventually purchase the Continuum and the Calcium K-line and use them both; that is what I did and if you are trying to squeeze all the detail out of white light viewing the Calcium K-Line is something you should consider.
After reading all the hype on the internet about the K-Line I was somewhat disappointed but still happy with the final results. I do see differences in the images produced with this filter and can appreciate what it brings to Solar Imager's everywhere. I wish I had an opportunity to purchase a 2" version, this would at least make my set more streamlined.
I can recommend this Baader Calcium K-Line for anyone wanting to do solar imaging and have some extra $$ you can spare. Look up and keep watching the sky.
|Mount Mfg||Losmandy G11 Gemini 2 Go To|
- 127MM APO Triplet
- 80mm APO Triplet
- Baader Continuum
- Baader Calcium K-Line
- Badder Solar Herschel Wedge
- Baader ND Filters
- Lunt Solar Wedge
|Original Date||9/12/2015 12:01:00 AM|