When I first got word Nikon was to release a new Phase Fresnel Super Telephoto my Intel was a bit off - I thought it would be a 600mm PF but instead, Nikon announced the 500mm f/5.6E PF ED VR. That being said. WOW! Nikon is stepping up their game with super-prime less than 4K. The Nikkor 500mm PF EF f/5.6 opens the gates for those on a moderate budget and looking for a longer prime under 4k, the new lens comes in around $3695.00, I understand it is not exactly cheap but compared to the 500mm f/4 it is a bargin.
After many years of using the older 300mm f/4 lens, I jumped at the new 300 PF lens when it was released and it is awesome - super sharp, compact and light. Enter the new 500mm f/5.6E PF ED VR and this new lens looks to be following the same compact lightweight footsteps as the 300mm.
If you need a 500mm prime under 4k Nikon offers one option the Nikkor 500mm f/5.6 PF lens. But is it worth the $3600 price tag or should you go with the more versatile and economical 200-500 for less than $1,500.00? The Nikon 200-500mm is such a compelling lens and matches the focal length and f stop of the 500mm /5.6 PF lens.
I feel the Nikon 500mm f/5.6 PF lens is geared to the pro enthusiast who demands a long prime lens but will not or can not shell 10K+ for the opportunity to own the faster 500 f/4 or 600mm for that matter. Considering this was announced when the Z series cameras - it shows how much Nikon is in the game for photography and thinking of smaller, lighter gear.
Prime 500mm f/5.6 vs 200-500 f/5.6 zoom - My thoughts: I prefer primes but appreciate the flexibility of zooms, This will be a hellish decision for many and given my track record for longer zooms, I think I would just shell out the extra cash and get the 500mm Prime, it will be faster focus, offer more energetic weather sealing and to me, that means longevity, use and resell. + almost half the weight of many of the zooms - 3.2 pounds vs 5+ pounds for the zoom. If you want to travel light and carry a super-telephoto then the Nikon 500mm PF is a good choice.
If you are on a tighter budget - the 200-500mm f/5.6 has many positive reviews, and some of the images taken with the 200-500mm lens are remarkably sharp. At the end of the day Nikon has given you two nice choices - now the only problem is choosing which one.
Why Choose the 500mm Nikkor over zooms that cover the 500/600mm range? You choose the Nikkor 500mm PF if you demand the highest quality without compromise for a rugged fully weathered sealed prime lens and want Nikon glass on your Nikon Camera with minimal weight.
Why Choose a 500/600mm zoom over the Nikkor 500mm PF? You don't shoot in foul weather, you have other photography interest but do wish to occasionally shoot wildlife/nature/birds, the flexibility the zoom is a key factor, and most of all cost savings.
If you shoot in poor weather conditions I would consider the 500mm PF lens to be the first choice over the 200-500mm. Me personally I never liked lenses that are not internal focus/zoom because each time the lens is extended and retracted the air is pulled and pushed inside the lens with the eventual introduction of dust.
The downside to the 500mm PF lens is the starting aperture of 5.6 which basically limits you to only the TC1.4 extending the zoom out to 700mm FOV equivalent but with an aperture of 7.8 and at the maximum of what the current cameras can focus with and even with my 600mm f/4 I sometimes wish it was a faster lens.
Below is a breakout of possible choices to help scratch your itch for a Long lens.
||Choices for 500mm under $6,000.00
|| Nikkor 500mm PF f/5.6
||Yes - Pro
|| Sigma 500mm f/4
|| 7.3 lbs
|| Yes - Pro
|| Nikon 200-500mm
|| 5.07 lbs
|| Tamron SP 150-600mm
|| 4.38 lbs
|| Sigma 150-600mm C
|| 4.3 lbs
|| Sigma 150-600mm S
|| 6.3 lbs
|| Sigma 60-600mm S
|| 5.95 lbs
On a Personal Note: I ordered my Nikkor 500mm f/5.6 PF back in Sept 2018 and on 11-03-2019 the lens was delivered, over one year. It is stated that Nikon is only making about 1000 per month. Thus if you are leaning toward the Nikkor 500mm and in an urgent need, they are available in limited numbers at some photo stores as of Nov 2019.
Now that I have my copy I will update this article with some photos and provide details on the overall performance with my D850, Z7, and Z6 cameras. The two test shots out the back door of my house of some fall foliage provided very vibrant colors and incredible sharpness.
Order Your Nikon 500mm PF f/5.6