Search
Saturday, September 23, 2017

The Toad Blog

My blogs about anything related to photography, and equipment, with a focus on non-technical enjoyment of photography. I like to publish these for the pure pleasure it brings. My equipment, and techniques shared here with a mix of landscape, macro, birds, flowers and all articles written by the person who uses the equipment - TrueToad.

The Toad Blog

DX vs FX Crop Sensor
TrueToad / Wednesday, May 4, 2016 / Categories: The Blog, Photography

DX vs FX Crop Sensor

Which is right for you

To baseline the discussion we will consider a comparison between two similar Mega Pixel sensor cameras, one being a DX (23.5 mm x 15.6 mm) and the other a FX sensor (35.9 mm x 23.9 mm), the DX & FX having the same number of pixel resolution - so, is there a difference?

DX and FX Sensors

DX and FX Sensors


Right off the bat you notice the a size difference as illustrated in the diagram, yellow portion represents the sensor, the DX sits well within the larger FX sensor, this matters to some degree throughout the article. When I say sensor size I am speaking about the physical size.

Sensor Size VS Image Quality: Let’s dive into this urban legend. Sensor size matters to some degree for a number or reasons, but is not necessarily a big factor in everyday use.  What drives image quality if we remove the lens as a factor? Consider two sensors both having 24MP.  Sensor (1 is DX), in order to cram 24 million of light gathering diodes onto a fixed size sensor each light gathering diode has to be of a certain size – see where I am headed with this? So DX sensors as compared to the FX sensors will in most situations have smaller light gathering diodes. On FX sensors there is more room on the larger sensor and thus the light gathering diodes can be larger. Larger diodes normally have better light sensitivity and dynamic capabilities – as a general statement. In most everyday use for posting photos on websites, or producing regular sized prints you will be hard pressed to notice ANY real difference between DX & FX, otherwise pros would not use crop sensor cameras along with their pro bodies. Where things begin to become more noticeable is when we drive the cameras into higher ISOs & more difficult lighting situations, then try to produce very large prints or 100% closeups. Why do smaller sensors begin to show noise at comparable ISOs/shooting situations? 

Factor in the “Engine” of the Camera: Everyone knows newer software and hardware normally makes images look better, as the cameras technology progresses so does the ability of the processor to deal with “noise & artifacts” more quickly, and more efficiently, camera manufactures work hard to optimize algorithms that help produce better images. What most of us are starting to see is the gap shrink between sensor sizes when used within the “normal”  casual range or use, because we have newer faster “camera processors" both Canon and Nikon take turns leap frogging each other.  Electronics have a lot to do with the image quality, as light gathering diodes are more closely packed onto smaller sensors so increases the “noise”.   Back in the day, medium format cameras produced better images than 35mm, the ratio of negative to print size; today we are dealing with electronics and variations of sensor sizes coupled with the density of diodes on the sensors. So, that larger sensor can have larger diodes and usually edges out in performance once you move into higher ISOs, and while newer camera processors make smaller sensors perform better they also make larger sensors perform better.. Win Win for everyone. So nowadays, you see DX cameras produce quality on par with FX especially if the FX is running older software/hardware.

What about the CROP Factor:  The funny thing is, if you never use a FX camera and only use DX cameras, chances are you don’t even know the difference exist. It becomes noticeable when switching between "systems". Example: If you are a FX users and love using a 24mm on a FX camera you know generally what Field of View (FOV) you will get based on our past experience.  When planning a shooting session we can grab a lens with confidence, knowing we will have the right FOV to capture what our intentions are. But if you change systems to a DX and slap that 24mm on a DX camera body the FOV changes because the sensor is smaller – hence the term crop factor.  In this situation the 24mm will look more like a 35mm, 36mm to be exact, this is not a bad thing just different, requiring you to make this consideration when shooting DX.

Why is this? In the simplest terms possible – the image being projected from the rear lens element will exceed the boundaries of a DX sensor. The sensor will be capturing the central most portion of the image projection.  An FX lens on a FX camera will project the image to the edge of the sensor capturing the entire image. See the illustration. This gives the impression of magnification on the DX sensor while the FX will show the entire image on the sensor, not a portion of it. To get the same effect with a FX you would need to zoom in 1.5 to fill the sensor.  Home work example: Draw a 1 inch square and a 2 inch square, now drop a penny on the 1 inch square, and slide it over to the 2 inch square. Compared to the 1 inch square the edges of the penny will overlap on the 1 inch, while the 2 inch will include the entire penny, and if processed this digitally, Abes head would appear larger on the smaller sensor, because a portion fills up more space than on the 2 inch square.

So what is the difference between FX and DX lens: Not much really at least for Nikon, at the end of the day, both serve the same purpose when used with the intended camera system.  DX lenses are engineered for DX cameras body, are normally smaller, lighter Cheaper :)  as compared to the larger FX lenses (larger glass=more weight & cost).  In most situations FX lenses work perfectly fine on DX cameras, while all DX lens may not work properly on a FX camera body due to the image projection from the rear DX lens element was not designed for FX sensors, thus you may have dark/black corners when using some DX lens on FX cameras, Tamron 11-20mm (DX) is a good example, this lens is designed for DX cameras, the lens will not fully cover the FX sensor until you zoom out to 16mm and beyond, it works fine at 16mm and beyond but not at the wide end.

Depth of Field: Something else we must mention when speaking about crop sensors and lenses like the crop the DX also influences depth of field (DOF). More compressed on DX, this issue might be less of a concern for most folks. As an example using a 35mm will have a DOF more like a 50mm. Unless you concentrate on DOF as a primary objective in you photographic compositions, it will be not too much of a concern.

Does the crop factor work for me or against me:  Both. Let’s take the positive first. If you like longer lens and have a passion for outdoor wildlife, bird and sports photography – you are in luck. DX cameras help get you closer. That cheaper 300mm f/4 will become a 450mm on a DX, then slap on a 1.4 TC and you’re out to 630mm 5.6 FOV.

On the down side: if you like the wide side of things, the wide angle lens also have the same crop factor, and in order to go wide you need a real wide lens. But don’t fret, the DX market has it covered, just need to be aware of the 1.5 crop when shopping for the wide lens. 

Why can’t I just buy a FX camera and set it to CROP mode when I need it: Good news is, you can! Many newer FX cameras offers a CROP mode in camera.  The side story to this is: consider both camera examples above as having 24mp sensors. When you set the FX camera to internal 1.5 crop mode you lose some of that wonderful 24 MP resolution & your optical view (what you see) has not changed from full frame FX mode, you may see a rectangular boundary box as you peer through the camera, but trust me, you sometimes forget you are shooting in crop mode, and anything outside the bounding box will be lost and in the heat of the moment, ooops.. While DX cameras will retain the full (sensor mega pixel) 24mp for this discussion, and your optical view will remain constant, IMHO it is best to use DX for situations needing longer lens vice a FX camera in crop mode, but it is doable with a FX.

You never answered the question, what should I get a DX or FX: Today, I don’t have a hugh argument one way or the other. My first digital camera was an Olympus 3mp camera costing $900.00, expensive at the time and I though I would never need another camera, the sensor of the Olympus  was smaller than a DX sensor and I was happy with that until I got my hands on a Nikon D70 and started using my older film lens on the D70 camera. Remembering back, those first FX cameras were very expensive and the camera companies were in a race of the MegaPixels more than anything.

The fact is, nowadays you could be completely happy with either format.

If I were to do it all again, I would have skipped the Olympus and started with a FX DSLR then purchased a DX body, with lenses being primarily made up of FX since they work on the DX camera, only exception to this is a couple DX lens for light weight travel – sometimes you just want to travel without the hassle of added weight. By the way, I have CX sensor camera (even smaller than DX) @ 2.7 crop, and I enjoy using it, and at times astounds me with the speed of focus and the quality of images it produces for such a small sensor camera.  This is exactly my set up today I use my FX, DX and my CX along side each other, without worries of which is better - each has benefits.

One final: Nikon is the only Camera company who most cleanly supports the use of Nikkor lenses on on their FX - DX - CX camera bodies.  I can use my 600mm on my FX, my DX outright and my little CX with the FT-1 adapter.

Print
Rate this article:
5.0
6720
Photographer's Notes

I have a fondness for the DX and use both DX and FX sensor cameras in my photographic endeavors.  

Lens
  • Sigma 8mm F3.5 EX DG Circular Fisheye
  • Tokina AT-X 11~20mm f/2.8 Pro DX
  • Nikkor 16-35mm f/4G ED VR
  • Nikkor 24mm f/3.5D ED PC-E
  • Sigma 35mm F1.4 DG HSM Art
  • Nikkor 45mm f/2.8D ED PC-E
  • Nikkor 300mm f/4 PF ED VR
  • Nikkor 400mm f/2.8 ED FL VR
  • Nikkor 600mm f/4 FL ED VR
Camera Body
  • Nikon 1 V3
Accessories Used
  • TC-14E III

2 comments on article "DX vs FX Crop Sensor"

2
0

John Montfort

I very much enjoyed your article on DX vs. FX and as I own lenses and camera bodies in both formats (all Nikon), I thought I would add my experiences.

(1) In regard to lenses for DX, there are many who lament the lack of choices from Nikon. However, there are quite a number of advantages of using FX lenses on DX bodies that I have personally experienced. Though great optically in the center area, many FX lenses have issues in the corners, such as astigmatism, vignetting, general softness, CA, distortion etc. All of these problems are minimized when used on a DX format camera. I will take just one lens of Nikon, the 80-400mm f4.5-5.6 VR as an example. This lens suffers a bit in the corners as well as having the usual vignetting when used wide open. On a DX camera these shortcomings are mostly eliminated, with the added benefit of having a longer reach. (120-600mm 35mm equivalent)

(2) A few DX lenses are actually superior to their FX cousins. One such lens is the new DX 16-80mm F2.8/4. Compare this lens on a D7200 to the 24-120mmF4 on a D750 and you will discover the DX to be sharper, much lighter, and at the wide end, 1 stop brighter.

(3) If you are having to attach teleconverters to your lenses for that extra reach, then DX is a no brainer. It is better to get that extra reach with the DX format rather than having that extra glass on your best telephoto lens. Not only are you slightly compromising the optical path but you are loosing at least one stop of light. That loss often caused focus problems as well as loss of aperture control over a wide range.

I use my DX (I now own the D500) as my travel camera body and my wildlife camera. My FX D800 is best suited for exceptional landscape photography, and my D750 to the larger animals in the world of nature. Although FX does give a one stop or better improvement in low light, that only holds if the lens does not require a teleconverter.

I personally think that DX may come back as a roaring Lion. Just as the big advantage Medium format had over FX has dwindled over the years, so has the advantages of FX over DX. If Nikon did one thing right, it was to make their lenses work on virtually all of their better camera bodies.


2
0

TrueToad

John, Thanks for taking time to write up such great insightful thoughts and provide your experience to the community. Well received by me and the many more who shall visit. Open honest two-way sharing is pivotal for continued growth - Thank You, I grew a bit today!

Please login or register to post comments.

Name:
Email:
Subject:
Message:
x

Sigma 180 Macro Lens Review

Sigma 180 Macro Lens Review Read more

This week I bring to you a full two years of the Sigma 180mm Macro lens. Is it a solid lens and worth the price? Does it deliver as a medium telephoto? Can you use this lens as your go to portraiture lens. Over the course of two years now, I will give you my opinion and a few Macro shots.

Savage Product Pro Led Light Table Review

Savage Product Pro Led Light Table Review Read more

Do you need a small led light table for your ads for selling of your products or used gear, if so read on about the Savage Product Pro Led Light Table.  A somewhat straightforward approach for obtaining pleasing images of the smaller type products you wish to sell or place in ads.  In operation, it is simple to use and the results are good.  Read the full review here....

Black & Yellow Garden Spider

Black & Yellow Garden Spider Read more

Over the last few years I became interested in the Orb Spiders, in particular the Black and Yellow Garden Spider as the common name or the Argiope aurantia, scientific name. Ultimately my fascination for spiders and insects in general always cause me to stop and take a closer look when I run across them out in the wild. As a photographer I enjoy taking a few photos at any opportunity, here in this write up I share my observations and images of the Black and Yellow Garden Spider.

Macro Photography Best Lens

Macro Photography Best Lens Read more

I spent a few hours outdoors enjoying my macro photography and I hope you enjoy and find inspiration in the images I captured. What do I use for my Macro setup and why?  read on...

Nikon D85O Real World Review

Nikon D85O Real World Review Read more

My Intel back in 2016 was close to what Nikon announced in the next release of the 800 series, the D850.   This camera is CLOSE to a game changer and now that I have mine let me give you my initial input.

Thank You Nikon!

Thank You Nikon! Read more

Thank you Nikon for being a wonderful company. In particular as my camera company of choice, I could not think of photography without Nikon as being part of it.

Wood Duck Photography

Wood Duck Photography Read more

I was not all that lucky in previous years of getting any real useable photos of Wood Ducks in the location I lived, due to the scarcity and short time frame they seem to stay in this area during the late spring season.  I find the Wood Duck a stunningly beautiful waterfowl. The males in particular with iridescent browns, blacks, white green, ornate patterns on nearly every feathe, this is one pretty bird.   Females very attractive but have a less colorful pattern but the same distinctive profile and delicate white pattern around the eye. I find Wood Ducks in the wooded marsh ares that have hardwood forest adjacent to the water.  With some research I discovered they nest in holes in trees or use man made nest boxes. Little did I know they are one of the few duck species with claws that can grip bark and perch on branches- see my photos of a group perching.

Cedar Waxwing

Cedar Waxwing Read more

Each year I am blessed by the migration of the Cedar Waxwing, Bombycilla cedrorum through my area of the country. Their visits are timed almost perfectly with the arrival of the fruiting trees and bushes.  These delightful birds will stay in the area for several months basically as long as the fruit holds out. See my gallery and read more on these birds.

Flower Photography

Flower Photography Read more

I have a couple photographic weakness, Birds and Flowers.  Whenever I am out doing some photography shooting regardless what my intentions are, if i run across a great looking flower I stop and take a photo or try to incorporate the flower into my scene. The great thing about flower photography is you really dont need any specialized equipment.  I have even taken flower photos with a fish eye lens. I you want to discover more about flower photography read on...

Rainy Day Photography

Rainy Day Photography Read more

I admit I like being out during rainy days  Why?  It is refreshing and stimulating to walk a wooded trail hearing and feeling the rain,  and besides that, It offers many opportunities for photographers - if we come prepared.

Lower Cost Wildlife Kit

Lower Cost Wildlife Kit Read more

You probably noticed most of my blogs cover the upper end of the Photo Spectrum. I owe it to many my recommendation for getting a 90% solution for fantastic wildlife photography.

Stellarvue SVR102T Review

Stellarvue SVR102T Review Read more

I have been around the Astronomy community for some time with many telescope adventures under my belt. One of the scopes that I was looking to acquire is a nice 4" refactor, not just any refactor but a premium performer, capable of doing what I wanted to do visually and imaging wise, my choice was.....

Rest in Peace Easter

Rest in Peace Easter Read more

Our family feline of 13 years passed away early this morning, bringing to closure Easter's wonderful life with our family. At his passing he was believed to be 20 years + of age. Everyone in his family will miss his presence and are saddened by the loss of  our cat Easter. He is survived by Teeny his fellow feline house companion, and three caretakers who provided and received his love over the years. 

Nikon WT-7

Nikon WT-7 Read more

This is a write up from Don C who added an extensive "comment" to my WT-7 post/review. I though it was worthy of an individual post.

The remainder of this post is Don's comments: I decided to breakdown and purchase the WT-7a,..being that 1) I own a D500, and 2) I love to shoot untethered. Note, my forte' in the photography world is "Event Photography. That is, capture and print "onsite". It's 90% of my business model and every since the days of the mighty D2X and WT-2a, I've always admired the ability of "capturing and image and it instantly popping up on a display monitor" for customers to see, and of course, buy prints! Well, time has changed since those 'good old days' to newer 'good old days' of the D500 and WT-7a!

Woodland Photography

Woodland Photography Read more

I truly enjoy the outdoors especially during spring months, plants and animals begin to flourish and the forest comes alive with colors, sound with a calm atmosphere.

Great Blue Heron

Great Blue Heron Read more

I am lucky to live in an area that the Great Blue Heron is found in most of the year. Here in North Va, you can expect to see the Great Blue Heron in numbers starting in Mid April through Late September. I really enjoy watching and photographing these birds. They are large and somewhat predictable and with some good planning you can acquire a few good photos on most occasions..

Photo Storage +

Photo Storage + Read more

So, you are an avid photographer with thousands of images in your collection.  Maybe you have been relying on an USB 3 external drive to as your file backup along with your lightroom database;  one copy on your work computer and a backup on the external - does this sound familiar?  While that approach is a viable one, you just might be at risk of serious data loss.  Here is my story on the near loss of many years of work, and why I decided to go pro, and invest in a serious NAS.

DX or FX Camera Bodies

DX or FX Camera Bodies Read more

This is about using a DX camera body or FX body with teleconvertor. Which combination is better?  I am sent this question many times - it depends...  

Wimberly CK-100 Sidemount

Wimberly CK-100 Sidemount Read more

This is my review of the Wimberley CK-100 Sidemount Conversion Kit.  I have owned the Wimberley WH-200 Gimbal Tripod Head II with Quick Release Base for a couple years without any issues.  But, I was looking for a more compact setup to use.  I ran across the sidemount kit from Kimberley and decided to give it a try.

Coming of Spring

Coming of Spring Read more

This wonderful Male Cardinal sits on a perch as sleet comes raining down, and is undaunted by the ice crystals that are falling on his face and feathers. The Cardinal is a native species of North America and suited for the elements, he appears well protected from these elements.  

RSS

Get Wired

Clever Machines Learn How to Be Curious (And Play Super Mario Bros.)

  • 23 September 2017
  • Author: TrueToad
  • Number of views: 0
  • 0 Comments
Clever Machines Learn How to Be Curious (And Play Super Mario Bros.)
Computer scientists are finding ways to code curiosity into intelligent machines.

Hackers Break Into the SEC, DHS Tells 21 States Russian Hackers Targeted Them, and More Security News This Week

  • 23 September 2017
  • Author: TrueToad
  • Number of views: 0
  • 0 Comments
Hackers Break Into the SEC, DHS Tells 21 States Russian Hackers Targeted Them, and More Security News This Week
An SEC hack, a Russian dark web takedown, and more security news this week.

What's So Great About Kids Fighting Monsters?

  • 23 September 2017
  • Author: TrueToad
  • Number of views: 0
  • 0 Comments
What's So Great About Kids Fighting Monsters?
Stories like the one in 'It' are pretty common in horror, but audiences never tire of them.

Space Photos of the Week: Spiral Galaxy's Secretly a Giant Gasbag

  • 23 September 2017
  • Author: TrueToad
  • Number of views: 0
  • 0 Comments
Space Photos of the Week: Spiral Galaxy's Secretly a Giant Gasbag
Cassini takes one last look at Saturn's moon, Jupiter's swirling clouds, and a star in a great big bubble this week in space.

London Wants to Kick Uber Out of the City

  • 23 September 2017
  • Author: TrueToad
  • Number of views: 0
  • 0 Comments
The ride-hailing company's offensive? Waging a popularity contest.
RSS
Copyright 2017 TrueToad Terms Of Use Privacy Statement
Back To Top